Choosing the right shingles

By Jenny Walvoord, The Third Estimate.

The right shingles can make or break your roof — literally and financially.

Your roof does more than keep the rain out — it defines your home’s look, protects against the elements and affects long-term value. When it’s time for a replacement, choosing between 3-tab and architectural shingles isn’t just about price — it’s about durability, curb appeal and investment. The difference isn’t just cosmetic; it’s structural. Before you settle on a roofing material, here’s what The Third Estimate believes you need to know to make the best decision for your home.

Understanding the difference: 3-tab versus architectural shingles

What are 3-tab shingles?

3-tab shingles are the traditional choice for many homes. They are:

• Built to last – With multiple layers of asphalt, these shingles hold up against tough weather and daily wear.
• Stylish design – They mimic the look of wood shakes or slate, giving your roof a more polished, upscale appearance.
• Wind-resistant strength – Many are rated to withstand winds up to 130 mph, offering better protection during storms.
• Long-term value – With a lifespan of 30+ years (some lasting 50+), they’re an investment in your home’s future.

These shingles were the standard for decades, but as technology advanced, homeowners started opting for a stronger, more visually appealing alternative — architectural shingles.  

What are architectural shingles?

Architectural shingles are built to last and add style to your home. Unlike traditional 3-tab shingles, they’re thicker, more durable and offer a high-end look. Here’s what makes them a great choice:

• Multiple layers of asphalt, making them thicker and more durable
• A high-end look, mimicking wood shakes or slate
• Superior wind resistance, often rated for 130 mph winds
• A lifespan of 30+ years, with some lasting 50 years or more

Unlike 3-tab shingles, architectural shingles aren’t just about function — they also dramatically improve your home’s curb appeal. Check out the Owens Corning architectural shingles we use.

Why choose architectural shingles over 3-tab?

At The Third Estimate, we exclusively install architectural shingles because we believe in their quality, durability and long-term value. Here’s why we think they’re the best choice:

1 – Superior durability & wind resistance

Weather is unpredictable. High winds, heavy rain and snow can take a toll on your roof. Architectural shingles are built with:

• SureNail® Technology from Owens Corning, improving nail grip and wind resistance
• A 130-mph wind rating, compared to 3-tab’s 60-70 mph
• Better impact resistance, helping withstand hail and falling debris

Read more about signs you may need a roof replacement.

2 – Longer lifespan and better warranty

With a roof replacement, you want peace of mind. Architectural shingles last nearly twice as long as 3-tab shingles and Owens Corning’s limited lifetime warranty ensures lasting protection.

3 – Enhanced curb appeal and home value

Architectural shingles elevate your home’s appearance. The layered design creates a dimensional look that can mimic high-end materials like slate or cedar shake. Homebuyers also favor homes with architectural shingles over 3-tab, increasing resale value.

• Available in a variety of colors and styles to match any home aesthetic
• Increases curb appeal, making your home stand out in the neighborhood
• A smart investment, often providing a higher return on resale

4 – Energy efficiency and algae resistance

Architectural shingles from Owens Corning offer additional benefits:

• Cool roof technology to reflect heat and reduce energy bills
• StreakGuard™ Algae Resistance, preventing black streaks
• Better insulation, keeping your home comfortable year-round

How to decide on the right shingles for your home

If you’re debating between 3-tab versus architectural shingles, ask yourself:

• Should I choose a roof that lasts 15 years or is a 30+ year option better for me?
• Is worrying about wind damage worth it or would I rather have peace of mind with a 130-mph wind rating?
• Would a basic, flat look suit my home, or should I go for a roof that adds character and enhances curb appeal?
• Is a lower upfront cost my priority or am I looking for a long-term investment in durability and value?

If you answered yes to durability, beauty and long-term investment — architectural shingles are the clear winner.

Original article and photo source: The Third Estimate